Thursday, August 9, 2012

The Curious Politics of Beasts of the Southern Wild

The newly released movie Beasts of the Southern Wild, by first-time Director Benh Zeitlin, has received critical praise and garnered prestigious awards on the film festival circuit, winning prizes at the Sundance and Cannes film festivals. The attention is understandable; the film is beautifully shot - the characters and story are compelling.  Zeitlin has charmed film fans with his do-it-yourself ethos and his warm embrace of the Louisiana Bayou community where the film was shot.   It might seem churlish to critique this engaging film on political grounds. But since it takes place within a poor and isolated community called the Bathtub on the eve of a Katrina-like storm, it is impossible not to read it politically.

The central character in the movie is a young girl called Hushpuppy. Hushpuppy is a survivor in the Bathtub's squalid world of alcoholism, filth, and outright child abuse.  The adult residents of the Bathtub, including her father, engage in spontaneous celebrations, drink incessantly and grab fish with their bare hands from the Bayou waters.  They are, according to a number of prominent film critics, "free." Writing in the New Yorker, David Denby concluded that the residents of the Bathtub "just want to enjoy, in liberty, their own special existence, which for them provides satisfactions as complete as any they know of."  The reviewer from the New Orleans based Times-Picayune newspaper (the film was shot just outside of New Orleans) asserts that the film portrays a band of "survivors who are willing to fight all day for their right to eat and drink, sing and stumble all night."

While the film centers on Hushpuppy's struggle to survive the degradation that surrounds her - primarily through imagination and her incipient art - this "You've got to fight for your right to party" ethos is also a central theme. Viewers are asked to interpret a lack of work discipline, schooling, or steady institution building of any kind - the primary building blocks of civilization - as the height of liberation. "Choice," even the choice to live in squalor, is raised to the level of a categorical imperative. There is no inkling of the economic and social history of the region that had limited these "choices." We are left with a libertarian sandbox, with a rights-based philosophy gone rancid.

The images in the film conjure up a debate about the political potential of the disenfranchised that took place in mid-nineteenth century Europe between Communist Karl Marx and Russian anarchist Mikhail Bakunin.   Marx was skeptical of the political and social potential of what he termed the "lumpen-proletariat," those on the margins of society who lived not unlike the residents of the Bathtub.  They were difficult to organize and incapable of adopting a coherent political ideology. They could, Marx believed, raise a lot of hell through spontaneous outbursts of hopeless insurrection, but they could not build a new society to challenge the dominant capitalist one.  Bakunin, on the other hand, championed the revolutionary potential of the "uncivilized, the disinherited, the miserable, the illiterate" who would eventually throw off their oppressive chains through violent revolt. In more recent times, Bakunin's beliefs were embraced by both Franz Fanon, the widely read French/Algerian psychiatrist and author of The Wretched of the Earth, and New Left philosopher Herbert Marcuse who, in the 1960s, extolled the "outcasts and outsiders," the "unemployed and unemployable" as a potential source of redemption from a "one dimensional" exploitative society.  This disenfranchised stratum, according to Bakunin, had not become "bourgeoisified" like organized workers who were beginning to extract concessions from their economic and political rulers.

In an attempt to save the Bathtub from flooding, a small band of residents, seemingly on an anarchistic whim, dynamite a levee.  Hushpuppy, at the urging of the adults, initiates the blast. We are not shown the impact this has on people living on the levee's other side. In another 1960s-era motif, a hospital in the "city" is pictured as a place where you are ignored, "plugged into a wall" to rot. In actual developing countries, one of the first things that rural citizens demand from their "leaders" is adequate health care and hospitals.  But in Zeitlin's film world these basic features of modern life - places where millions of people are actually cared for and healed - are represented as oppressive institutions, places we need to escape.

These images reprise some of the ideas familiar not just to Marcuse, but to writers as diverse as Ken Kesey, Michel Foucault and Christopher Lasch.   Lasch railed against agencies of the state, "professional caretakers," and centralizing bureaucracies that threatened to undermine familial and local commitments and obligations that were essential to a healthy civil society.  The feeling of being disciplined and punished by cold and bureaucratic agents of social control seems to resonate with a good portion of moviegoers, not to mention voters.  What social and psychological storms threaten us so much that even the technology of flood control can seem a "restrictive" interference with our freedom? Has the "State" truly become a self-perpetuating machine of repression, or are the burdens of modernity so inherently alienating that juvenile rebellion feels like liberty?

 In his new book The Age of Fracture, Princeton historian Daniel Rogers suggests that post-World War II American history has seen a "disaggregation of the social" where the broad social contract that had brought more and more Americans into the domain of full economic and political citizenship has dramatically shrunk. We are left with smaller and smaller visions of "community," often being reduced to the level of a single "rights-holding self."  In a sad way, the characters in the characters in Beasts of the Southern Wild are an artistic reflection of this fragmented world.

One of the great psychological insights in Beasts of the Southern Wild is that there is more to us than the environment that supposedly "shapes" us. The creative force is always potentially available, struggling to emerge. At the end of the movie the small band of brothers and sisters who remain in the Bathtub march together along what looks like a cement retaining wall as water laps over their feet. There is calm before the next storm.  One of the marchers carries a black flag (a pirate flag? the black flag of anarchy?) Are they marching to petition the county government? To blow up another levee? To link in solidarity with fellow survivors nearby? It may be that they are merely marching home to have another drink.

For all the creativity and discipline invested in the making of this film, its political message seems dangerously hedonist - an apolitical, individualist hedonism with a tacked-on ending suggesting an incipient social movement.  Beasts of the Southern Wild will undoubtedly and deservedly win a number of Oscars next year.  I'm hoping that its troubling social message won't win adherents as well.

Find links to this article at the Los Angeles Book Review www.lareviewofbooks.org And at Salon - www.salon.com/2012/08/09/the_problematic_beasts_salpart/  

Further reading:

Michael Harrington - Socialism - for an outline of the Marx/Bakunin debate within the First International.

Herbert Marcuse - One-Dimensional Man - in the last chapter he makes the argument of how the "elementary force" of the outsiders and outcasts might mark the end of a political period.

Daniel T. Rodgers - The Age of Fracture

28 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Much like Safari, the Camera app, the App Store and i - Pod, Game Center has no
    option to be deleted when editing your apps.

    The only downside of it in a lot of people's eyes is the fact that there is no multiplayer content. The main reason why you would want to do this is simple, you can unlock the true potential of your purchase.

    Also visit my blog post; ole com ar

    ReplyDelete
  10. For any kind of luxury item of consumption, MAD (Money, Authority
    and Desire) is required. Much of your best players marketplaces in the united states
    are supervised. Another radio commercial production tip to chew on is to make sure the audio quality is excellent on any spot your produce.


    Look at my site :: http://www.online-radioportal.de/radio-player-2421_polskastacja___era_disco

    ReplyDelete
  11. Multiplayer versions is more exciting as in this, you'll be able to team up or even contend with other participants to defeat the enemies. If you don’t have much skill in programming, but still think that creating and developing games is the most suitable for you, there are special courses that will give you training in graphic designing, game development, and computer animation. It is recommended that the golfers select those putters with which the golfers feel good and works well with their gaming pattern.

    My web-site http://www.blesele.org/member/80295/

    ReplyDelete
  12. But with Nexus Radio the only settings you have to worry
    about are where you want to save your files and what file type
    you want to save it as. They also apparently believe that their
    customers who like a particular song they hear on the radio, are likely to purchase
    that song, which could add to downloads from i -
    Tunes. Another radio commercial production tip to chew on
    is to make sure the audio quality is excellent on any
    spot your produce.

    My weblog - radio vision 2000 haiti

    ReplyDelete
  13. The internet is fueling the success of music because it can be listened to
    at any time of the day and anywhere in the world.
    It was an entertaining radio program that played the music people wanted to hear combined with his groovy upbeat personality.
    Many people will be happy with replaceable batteries for
    home use and occasional outings.

    My homepage: radio kits 2005 altima alpine

    ReplyDelete
  14. Or, I've already hit bottom and I've nowhere to go but up.

    Here's a look at the his old buddies' post-"Friends" paths
    and where Dr. In other episodes, Ross makes fun of Rachel's male nanny, Ross and Phoebe get mugged, and Chandler and Monica visit a fertility clinic.

    Here is my webpage: Http://Schwimmerschalter24.De

    ReplyDelete
  15. They help separate the fishing men from the boys, so you can
    find an excellent guide who really knows what he's doing. You will also want to have a supply of different lines that you can use. Yet sometimes a net is better to use because it usually doesn't harm the fish
    and will most likely be easier for you to prepare the fish for later.


    Also visit my web blog - www.keepportlandweird.org

    ReplyDelete
  16. "It also brings artists' music-related Twitter activity front and center: go to their profiles to see which music artists they follow and listen to songs by those artists. The problem with social media is that for salespeople it can be used as an excuse not to pick up the telephone and actually make a call. Try to maintain a healthy 5:1 mix of other’s content to your own.

    Also visit my website; Fox News Twitter Account

    ReplyDelete
  17. If it is not, remove the receiving part of the mouse,
    the device plugged into the USB port, then reinsert it.
    I haven't really owned the mouse long enough to test the battery life, but Logitech claims it can run for up to two years on a single pair of batteries, and several other reviews I've
    found online attest to that fact. Building a better Naga -
    I've always really liked Razer's Naga (and I've used nearly all of them at some point), but I have to say that the G600 is hands-down my pick.

    Feel free to surf to my homepage - More Information and facts

    ReplyDelete
  18. For any kind of luxury item of consumption, MAD (Money, Authority
    and Desire) is required. Next, build a list of prospects and develop
    a relationship with those prospects on your list.

    Another radio commercial production tip to chew on is to make sure the audio quality is excellent on any spot your produce.


    Also visit my web blog :: radio offline

    ReplyDelete
  19. A little bit of care, concern and love will go a long way to
    make him feel bound with you. These are reaching thousands of people at a time who recognize the self help benefits and pass them on
    to friends who do the same and they become viral. So choose
    the perfect Funny Family Poems to surprise your mother and make it a special memory to always remember.


    My web page :: resource for this article

    ReplyDelete
  20. Enjoy the public open-air concept loo and shower area.

    If you own a Black - Berry 9550 Storm 2, Black - Berry Curve 8530, Black
    - Berry Tour 9630, Black - Berry Storm 9530, Black - Berry Curve 8330, Black - Berry World 8830, Black - Berry Pearl Flip 8230, or Black -
    Berry Pearl Flip 8130, then you can listen to nearly a thousand songs
    on a single micro - SD card. We are literally not the same person we were a minute ago, let alone a day, a month or a year ago.


    my web page; http://www.Banktown.Org/cgi-bin/Aska.cgi

    ReplyDelete
  21. Much like Safari, the Camera app, the App Store and i - Pod,
    Game Center has no option to be deleted when editing your
    apps. However, every character in the game (even supporting players) should be presented in this same detail.
    The most unique thing about Ouya is that it is said to be "open" -- although what this means
    is up for interpretation.

    Feel free to surf to my blog post; http://www.spielespielen24.de/action/kumite

    ReplyDelete
  22. This is more important than ever in a world where there are dozens of different audio formats.
    They also apparently believe that their customers who like a particular song they hear
    on the radio, are likely to purchase that song, which could
    add to downloads from i - Tunes. Many people will be happy with replaceable batteries for home use and occasional
    outings.

    My web site - learningatplay.blogspot.de

    ReplyDelete
  23. Multiplayer versions is more exciting as in this,
    you'll be able to team up or even contend with other participants to defeat the enemies. If you don’t have much skill in programming, but still think that creating and developing games is the most suitable for you, there are special courses that will give you training in graphic designing, game development, and computer animation. We carry R4 SDHC, DSTT, R4i SDHC, Acekard 2i, EZFlash Vi, M3i Zero, and now the i - Edge.

    My webpage: Suggested Webpage

    ReplyDelete
  24. I have interviewed a few parents to attempt to understand what
    their true objection is with their child playing video
    games. Understanding video gaming is a must tip
    on how to run a game store. You can only acquire a
    small amount of in-game money or gold, and cannot participate in the auction house, send mail,
    join guilds, or even whisper to someone unless someone whispers to you first.


    my web site ... logo game answers

    ReplyDelete
  25. After a long hectic busy day, games plays an important role to relax frayed nerves, scorched eyes and tired ears.
    True, but that does not make the games not less fun,
    or not less based on the movies. Everyone with plenty of cash to commit could
    be a winner at Small Hand Texas Holdem Poker soon after obtaining familiarized with a handful of primary dos and don'ts.

    Here is my website ... Globaltecags.wordpress.Com

    ReplyDelete
  26. And Ouya, which is about the size of a Rubik's cube. While having a passion for playing games is important, getting a rewarding career in game design will require students to be a cut above the competition. It is recommended that the golfers select those putters with which the golfers feel good and works well with their gaming pattern.

    my weblog: www.videomela.com

    ReplyDelete
  27. It bears mentioning that there are also games and
    simulations available to those wanting to learn to trade stock index futures.
    Age Level - A good factor to write about is the appropriate age level for the video game that you are reviewing.
    Harry Potter Hogwarts is one more entry into this new series of LEGO board games.


    Take a look at my webpage ... http://livingwaychristianfriendshipgroup.com/groups/fast-programs-of-game-straightforward-advice/

    ReplyDelete
  28. The radio itself is made for Pandora, seeing
    as how its remote had all the Pandora controls right on it.
    You can find more on the Best call - Recorder and other call recorders here.
    So the next time you want to listen to new music you wouldn’t here on commercial radio,
    consider Internet radio.

    Also visit my blog :: internetradio aussetzer

    ReplyDelete